ErikMcClure's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Reasoner- I'm Still Here]

A slow saturday

Is precisely what this sounded like. Superb job, and excellent as background music.

Reasoner responds:

:-)

[[Melophobia g-R]]

The melody sucks ass

But my god, the motif at 1:01 makes the whole song awesome beyond words. The fact that its beautifully mastered and mixed helps too.

10/10
5/5

[Rose At Nightfall]

Wow

This song starts off amazing, becomes incredible, goes into a breif bout of unbelievable, and is simply beyond words. This song is made of win.

10/10
5/5

NemesisTheory responds:

This review is made of win, too! <3
thank you for the kind words!

[Entrance Me (Original Mix)]

Good Ambient

Not entirely that good of a listening song, though. I can feel this song in the background somewhere, but its missing the variation and massive feel of your other songs. That massive synth seems a bit lonely and out of place with all the other light, ambient, echoey synths in the song. It might have worked if it was faded even more into the background, but when its trying to carry the melody it just doesn't fit.

Either way, a good job, just not a spectacular job.

8/10
5/5

Mrmilkcarton responds:

Hmmm thanks for the input. I think I could dramatically change the style of the song by removing and replacing that synthe. Always room to improve and makes me want to try even harder on the next track.

Thanks for the vote and review.

[~EnV~Heaven Rd. 3]

Jeez

Well I don't really care for the gigantic drum, and I don't particularly like the genre, this song demands respect for its stunning production and clear, professional sound. Good god, this song has talent in it.

[/M: Twilight To Mydnite]

Slow and lovely

I HEAR PACHEBELS CANON!

D:

Regardless of how much pachebel's canon is in this song, that is a truely lovely melody, and it really sings at the end of the song. The atmosphere achieved in this piece is really great, and gives a rather nostalgic feeling. I think some of the breaks are a little slow, and I would have liked a little more of the melody, but overall a great song.

Mich responds:

To be honest, I've never even heard of that 'Pachebels Canon'...
So That was not intended...

Thanks for your review!
-EDIT-
I looked that Pachelbel's canon thingy up, and it appears that I do know that :p

And you're right it sounds pretty much like it...
Still it wasn't intended...

[To the End of The World]

Wow

Now, normally I don't really like rock songs. however, this song is far more complex then i would ever have imagined a rock song to be, and goddamn, its awesome. You've been told a million times, but your amazing.

10/10
5/5

cazok responds:

Believe me, I never get tired of hearing people liking my songs :)

[F-777's-Air Fantasy{MilkMix}]

Divine

0:42 has the most amazing notes that I have ever heard come out of my speakers. This song doesn't need a review, the song itself demands nothing less then 10/10 and 5/5. This. Is. Amazing.

Mrmilkcarton responds:

Glad to be honored by your words.

[{DKL} -Below-]

Holy shit

You know, every now and then, I'll be listening to a song, and it will hit a part that is so unbelievably awesome, I say "Holy shit" out loud. This is one of them. Un-fucking-believable. The middle part has some weird tempos, but the pure, unholy awesomeness of the main chorus makes up for a billion times. You are a GOD.

DavidKrachtLam responds:

Thank you very much! I'm glad you like it! =)

[{DKL} A Happy Life (Classical)]

Strings! STRINGS!

This song is crying out for some deep, thick background strings to accompany the piano. Also, doing octaves in the left hand for extended periods of time is not recommended. Instead, try to put in some interesting patterns and arpeggios. Additional instruments would also help widen and round out the song. Either way, a nice melody, I just feel that it wasn't fully explored.

8/10
4/5

DavidKrachtLam responds:

Yeah well, it was totally remade from me playing it on piano, so I felt that I shouldn't have added more since well, this what was I could play.